Drugstore Dupe: For Benefit's Roller Lash!

Well hello there!

Lately my most very favourite thing to do is to find drugstore dupes for my beloved products from Sephora. Now this doesn't mean I'm switching everything that I'm using and it doesn't mean that I'm not either. I'm essentially doing this for fun, for my readers, and just to see whether or not if the products I'm using are really worth my (semi-hard earned) money.


I've been testing out a lot of mascaras within the last little while because that's something that's easily switchable. Yes, it's great to have a go-to and an essential in your makeup bag, but sometimes it's fun to have a whole bunch to try out for different looks. My favourite look is to have very separated/fanned out lashes with some thickness to them. To do that I use 2 different mascaras, Benefit's Roller Lash and Urban Decay's Perversion. While flipping through a magazine I happened to notice CoverGirl's new Super Sizer mascara that looked pretty similar to Benefit's, and since I knew it wouldn't make a huge dent in my pocket I decided to test it out!

mascara results
On the left side is Benefit's Roller Lash and on the right side is CoverGirl's Super Sizer (when looking at the pictures)

Obviously according to the title, the results were extremely similar. Both mascaras are intended to be twirled while applying to create a lengthier, more expanded and "real" looking set of lashes. Both brushes have small and big bristles to create the effect.

cover girl super sizer mascara

cover girl super sizer mascara

benefit rollerlash mascara

benefit rollerlash mascara

The only differences I found were with the CoverGirl Super Sizer, it's hard to twirl the brush because of the way it's designed, and with the way the bristles are it makes it easier to do the left eye (as I'm right handed) than the right. Other than that, the CoverGirl Super Sizer mascara is identical to Benefit's Roller Lash and it's a fraction of the price!

What do you think of each mascara?

P.S. Get 2 of my social media accounts to 500 followers each for a giveaway!



  1. You've found a great dupe there! I'm about to run out of roller lash so I'll definitely be picking that one up!


    1. Well thank you! I'm glad I could help out! :)


to top